The Bay Butcher

Holiday Standing Orders · Oyster Bay

Holidaysfill the book.

Thanksgiving, Christmas, Easter, Mother's Day. Reserve the cut with your name on it ahead of the week — we hold the case for the order.

A pasture-raised whole heritage bird for Thanksgiving at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay

01

Thanksgiving

Order by · Friday before

Heritage turkeys, whole and bone-in. Holiday roasts. Pre-orders fill the book by the Monday of the week — call early.

A dry-aged USDA Prime bone-in ribeye for a Christmas standing rib roast at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay

02

Christmas

Order by · December 18

Standing rib roasts, whole tenderloins, crown roasts of pork or lamb, suckling pig. Wine pairings on request.

An eight-rib Frenched rack of lamb for Easter at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay

03

Easter

Order by · Tuesday of Holy Week

Spring lamb, Duroc ham, eight-rib racks. The cellar fills with lighter aging windows.

A curated Mother's Day gift box of premium cuts at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay

04

Mother's Day

Order by · Thursday before

Curated gift boxes, His & Hers filet combos, surf & turf. Wrapped for the table.

Reserve a holiday cut

Phone the counter.

Holidays fill the book quickly. Call us early in the week and we'll lock the order in.

(516) 273-6733

Or see custom cuts →