The Bay Butcher

Oyster Bay · since 2020

A butcher and a seafood counter on South Street. Cut to order, served to standard.

Begin
Cleaver planted in a Prime ribeye beneath the knife rack

Dry-aged Prime · cut on order

N° 01

Meat

Cut to order,never to display.

Dry-aged USDA Prime beef, heritage Duroc pork, New Zealand lamb, and veal — broken down whole in the shop, portioned to your spec at the counter.

Tell us the table, the technique, the evening. The case is the conversation.

A tray of fresh oysters on crushed ice, held at the counter

Oyster Bay oysters · same-day

N° 02

Fish

Day-boat fresh,on ice by service.

Salmon, branzino, tuna, halibut, Chilean sea bass. Head-on shellfish — clams, oysters, mussels, lobster, crab. Specialty cuts: octopus, scallops, caviar.

With advance notice we can source seasonal fish to spec for your order.

Visit the shop

Come in.

Hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday – Saturday
12 — 6 pm
Sunday
10 am — 3 pm

Call ahead for special cuts, dry-aged whole loins, holiday standing orders, and the larger pieces — we hold the case for the order with your name on it. More about the shop we opened on South Street in 2020.