The Bay Butcher
A dry-aged USDA Prime bone-in ribeye steak at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

The Signature Selection

Onthe block.

A short list of names we carry because we know them. The case turns over daily — assume what's here is what's in the cellar today, and call if you want it held.

I. Beef

The dry-aged case.

Whole loins hung in the cellar. Cut on request.

60-Day Dry-Aged Strip — USDA Prime · Heartland at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

USDA Prime · Heartland

60-Day Dry-Aged Strip

Two months on the bone in our cellar. The most pronounced beef in the case.

Bone-In Dry-Aged Ribeye — USDA Prime · dry-aged 28+ days at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

USDA Prime · dry-aged 28+ days

Bone-In Dry-Aged Ribeye

Cut on request. Marbled, mineral, generous.

Dry-Aged Porterhouse — USDA Prime · for two at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

USDA Prime · for two

Dry-Aged Porterhouse

Strip and filet on one bone. The classic order for a serious table.

Allen Brothers Filet Mignon — USDA Prime Angus at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

USDA Prime Angus

Allen Brothers Filet Mignon

Trimmed and tied. The cut that needs nothing more than salt and heat.

Long-Bone Ribeye — USDA Prime · dry-aged at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

USDA Prime · dry-aged

Long-Bone Ribeye

Tomahawk profile. A piece you serve to friends who appreciate it.

II. Wagyu

Japan & Australia.

A5 from Niigata, grass-finished cross-breeds from Australia.

A5 Japanese Wagyu Tenderloin — Snow-aged · Niigata at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Snow-aged · Niigata

A5 Japanese Wagyu Tenderloin

Held in snow rooms before harvest. The most refined beef we carry.

Australian Wagyu Bavette — Wagyu cross · grass-finish at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Wagyu cross · grass-finish

Australian Wagyu Bavette

The chef's secret cut — bold flavour, generous marbling, never overwrought.

A5 Wagyu Cubes — Snow-aged · for the grill at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Snow-aged · for the grill

A5 Wagyu Cubes

Hand-cut. For yakiniku, skewers, or the most expensive bite of stew you'll ever serve.

III. Lamb

Sweet and clean.

Australian, frenched, Sunday-evening ready.

8-Rib Rack of Lamb — Australian · Frenched at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Australian · Frenched

8-Rib Rack of Lamb

Sweet, clean, beautifully framed. Built for an evening.

IV. Pork

Heritage Duroc.

Pasture-raised, deeply flavoured, properly fatty.

Duroc Baby Back Ribs — Heritage breed at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Heritage breed

Duroc Baby Back Ribs

Pasture-raised, mineral-fed Duroc. The pork our grandparents remember.

Duroc Bone-In Pork Chops — Heritage breed at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Heritage breed

Duroc Bone-In Pork Chops

Thick-cut, deeply marbled — the chop that earns a wine pairing.

Double-Smoked Bacon — Bakers Bacon · Massachusetts at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Bakers Bacon · Massachusetts

Double-Smoked Bacon

Cured slowly, smoked twice over applewood. Sliced to your spec.

The standard

Nothing on display is finished. Tell us the table — we cut to fit.

V. Poultry

Real chickens.

Pasture-raised. Cleanly cut. Never wet-packed.

Whole Heritage Chicken — Pasture-raised at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Pasture-raised

Whole Heritage Chicken

Bone broth structure, real chicken flavour. Roast it whole.

Free-Range Chicken Breast — Boneless · skinless at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Boneless · skinless

Free-Range Chicken Breast

Clean cut, never wet-packed. The weeknight workhorse.

VI. From the water

Sashimi-grade salmon, head-on shrimp.

Flown in. Iced down. Out within the day.

Big Glory Bay King Salmon — New Zealand · ocean-raised at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

New Zealand · ocean-raised

Big Glory Bay King Salmon

Buttery, jewel-red, sashimi-grade. Flown in for the case.

Atlantic Salmon Fillet — Center-cut · skin-on at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Center-cut · skin-on

Atlantic Salmon Fillet

Reliable, generous, easy to love. Always within an evening's reach.

Chilean Sea Bass — Center-cut fillet at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Center-cut fillet

Chilean Sea Bass

Snow-white flesh, gentle on the palate, ceremonial on the plate.

Cold-Water Lobster Tails — North Atlantic at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

North Atlantic

Cold-Water Lobster Tails

Heavy, sweet, perfectly portioned. Service-ready.

Black Tiger Shrimp — Head-on · jumbo at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Head-on · jumbo

Black Tiger Shrimp

Snap, brine, restaurant-grade presentation.

VII. Selections

Curated combinations.

Built for the table. Wrapped for the gift.

His & Hers Filet Combo — USDA Prime at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

USDA Prime

His & Hers Filet Combo

Two filets, gift-wrapped. The anniversary order.

King & Queen Combo — USDA Prime at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

USDA Prime

King & Queen Combo

Strip and filet — the case classic.

Steak Lovers' Assortment — Allen Brothers Angus at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Allen Brothers Angus

Steak Lovers' Assortment

A curated box of our most-asked-for cuts. Built for a long weekend.

Surf & Turf — Filet · lobster at The Bay Butcher, Oyster Bay, NY

Filet · lobster

Surf & Turf

The standing order for a serious evening.

Also at the counter

The full counter.

Day-to-day cuts that live in the case but don't make the showcase. With advance notice we can source a wide variety of fresh fish and seafood for your order.

Beef

  • Sirloin · bone-in & boneless
  • Skirt & flank
  • Tri-tip
  • Brisket · whole or trimmed
  • Short ribs
  • Stew & braise cuts
  • Ground · chuck and brisket-short rib blend
  • House meatballs

Charcuterie & cured

  • Bresaola
  • Prosciutto di Parma
  • Hot soppressata
  • Coppa
  • Dry Spanish chorizo
  • House sausages · sweet & hot Italian

Pork

  • Duroc baby back ribs
  • Duroc bone-in chops
  • Spiral-sliced ham
  • Bakers double-smoked bacon
  • Pancetta
  • Whole loin · on request

Poultry

  • Whole heritage chicken
  • Boneless skinless breast
  • Bone-in thighs
  • Drumsticks
  • Wings
  • Whole duck · on request
  • Heritage turkey · holiday only, pre-order

Seafood & shellfish

  • Atlantic salmon · skin-on, center-cut
  • King salmon · Big Glory Bay
  • Chilean sea bass
  • Tuna · sushi-grade, by request
  • Cod, halibut, branzino · seasonal
  • Black tiger shrimp · head-on jumbo
  • Cold-water lobster tails
  • Cooked lobster meat
  • Clams · littleneck & cherrystone
  • Oysters · East Coast selection
  • Mussels
  • Crab · seasonal
  • Day-boat fish · ask what came in today

48 hours for special orders. Whole-animal items, holiday standing orders, and sourcing for a specific dish — call the counter.

A note from the counter

Anything not here? Ask.

Suckling pig, crown roasts, whole tomahawks, holiday standing orders, sourcing for a specific dish. We need 48 hours, and we deliver to the standard.