The Bay Butcher

Shellfish · Cold-water

Cold-waterlobster.

Live Maine lobsters from the tank and cold-water tails on ice. The shellfish call we get most often — and the one we're most proud of.

From the counter

About lobster.

Lobster from cold water tastes better. Period. Slower growth, denser sweet meat, firmer texture. We work two sources: live Maine lobsters from the tank (1.25-2 lb selects, larger by request) and frozen cold-water tails (Canadian, 4-6 oz and 6-8 oz) for the nights you want it ready in minutes.

Picked lobster meat — claw + knuckle, sometimes tail — is in the case daily, cooked that morning. The good stuff for lobster rolls, salads, pasta. Sold by the half-pound.

We crack and split on request. Tell us if you're steaming, grilling, or roasting — the cut depends on the method.

At a glance

Live whole

1.25 – 2 lb standard · 3+ lb by request

Tails

4-6 oz · 6-8 oz · cold-water (Canadian)

Picked meat

Claw + knuckle · cooked that morning

Source

Maine / Atlantic Canada

Notice

Same-day for tank · 24 h for >3 lb specials

In the case

Lobster — 2
Lobster — 3

Cooking notes

How we'd cook it.

01 · Method

Steam, whole

Inch of water in a wide pot. Lobster in, head-first, lid on. 9 minutes for a 1.25 lb, 12 minutes for a 1.5 lb, 15 minutes for a 2 lb. Pull straight to an ice bath if you're salading; serve hot if you're plating.

02 · Method

Grill, split tails

Tail split lengthwise. Flesh-side up over medium-high. Brush with melted butter every 60 seconds. 5-7 minutes until just opaque. Squeeze of lemon.

03 · Method

Picked meat, lobster roll

Toss room-temp picked meat with mayo, lemon, chive, salt. Toasted top-split brioche bun rubbed with butter on both flat sides, griddled gold. Pile in, eat fast.

Hold one for me

Call the counter.

24 hours notice for special cuts, dry-aged whole loins, and holiday standing orders. We hold the case for the order with your name on it.